What is discogenic pain and how is it diagnosed?

Discogenic pain originates from the intervertebral disc itself, often due to annular tears or chemical irritation of internal nerve endings. Diagnosis is clinical and may be supported by imaging findings such as high-intensity zones (HIZ) on MRI, pain provocation during discography, or exclusion of other sources via diagnostic blocks.

Is provocative discography still used?

Yes, but selectively. Provocative discography involves pressurizing a spinal disc to reproduce the patient's typical pain. While its use has declined due to concerns about invasiveness and false positives, it can still be valuable in surgical planning for well-selected patients.

Can MRI alone confirm if the disc is the pain source?

No. While MRI can reveal features like annular tears, HIZ, Modic changes, and herniation, these findings must be correlated with patient history and clinical exam. Many asymptomatic patients also show disc abnormalities on MRI.

What are the best treatments for discogenic back pain?

Treatment options include physical therapy, intradiscal steroid injections, platelet-rich plasma (PRP), stem cell therapy, biacuplasty, and minimally invasive surgical techniques such as Disc-FX or endoscopic discectomy. Some biologic options are considered investigational and offered off-label with informed consent.

Are procedures like IDET still used?

No. Intradiscal Electrothermal Therapy (IDET) is now largely outdated due to limited effectiveness. Most modern spine practices favor biologics, targeted ablation, or minimally invasive disc interventions for more reliable outcomes.

Is back pain from a disc herniation permanent?

Not necessarily. Many cases improve with conservative care. For persistent symptoms, targeted therapies can provide long-term relief. Prognosis depends on the underlying pathology, treatment approach, and patient factors.

Back Pain Disc Herniation: 7 Surprising Facts

Posted on: Jun 3 2025
By: amits

📱
✉️
📘
💼
🐦
🖨️

Back pain disc herniation may sound like a contradiction. Classic medical teaching says disc herniation causes nerve root compression, leading to leg pain—not back pain. But for some patients, the disc itself is the problem.

Back pain disc herniation remains a complex clinical entity where structural damage doesn’t always explain the patient’s symptoms. This article explains when and why a herniated disc causes axial back pain, how to interpret imaging findings, and what treatments may help when conventional wisdom falls short.

1. Anatomy of the Intervertebral Disc

The disc sits between spinal bones and absorbs shock. It has a soft core (nucleus pulposus) and a tough outer ring (annulus fibrosus).

Pain-sensitive nerve endings called sinuvertebral nerves innervate the outer disc. Inflammation, tears, or internal pressure can activate these nerves, causing axial pain.

2. Key Definitions: Bulge vs Herniation vs Tear

Axial pain: Central back pain without leg symptoms
Radicular pain: Nerve pain down the leg from root compression
Disc bulge: Broad-based disc extension, often age-related
Protrusion/herniation: Focal outpouching of disc material
Annular tear: Disruption of annulus, often leading to inflammatory pain

3. How Common is Back Pain from Disc Herniation?

Studies show disc herniations are common in asymptomatic people. One-third of people over 40 may have them on MRI. True discogenic pain is less common but real, often linked to annular fissures or endplate inflammation (Modic changes).

4. When Does a Back Pain Disc Herniation Actually Hurt?

In some patients, the disc itself becomes a pain generator. This may occur due to an annular tear that exposes nerve endings to nucleus material. Patients typically describe a deep, constant ache worsened by sitting or forward bending. The pain rarely radiates past the gluteal region.

MRI may show a High-Intensity Zone (HIZ) on T2-weighted sequences—an imaging marker of annular tear—but this finding alone does not confirm the disc as the culprit.

5. The Diagnostic Dilemma

When a disc herniation presents without leg symptoms, it puzzles even experienced clinicians. Why?

Radiculopathy is expected with nerve compression.
Axial pain often points toward facet, SI joint, or muscular sources.
Yet, in a subset of patients, the herniated disc itself is painful—due to annular disruption or chemical irritation from nucleus pulposus leakage.

This overlap creates a diagnostic gray zone, requiring a skilled combination of history-taking, physical exam, and imaging interpretation. The challenge lies in determining whether a back pain disc herniation is the true generator of axial symptoms or merely an incidental finding.

6. What Imaging Can—and Can’t—Tell You

MRI is a crucial tool in evaluating spinal conditions, but it has limitations—especially when diagnosing discogenic back pain. While certain MRI findings may suggest that a disc is the pain generator, none are definitive on their own. Clinical context is essential.

High-Intensity Zones (HIZ): These appear as bright white signals within the posterior annulus on T2-weighted MRI. HIZs are thought to represent fluid-filled annular fissures and have been associated with painful discs in some studies. However, they can also be seen in asymptomatic individuals.
Modic Changes: These are degenerative signal changes in the vertebral endplates adjacent to the disc. Type I (inflammatory) Modic changes are most closely linked to pain and often coexist with annular tears or endplate disruption. Still, not all patients with Modic changes experience symptoms.
Loss of Disc Height or Hydration: Seen as a “black disc” on T2 sequences, this finding reflects disc degeneration. It may indicate structural compromise, but by itself does not confirm the disc is painful.

Ultimately, these imaging findings may support the diagnosis of discogenic pain—but they must align with the patient’s symptoms, physical exam, and exclusion of other sources such as facet joints or sacroiliac dysfunction.

MRI findings in a back pain disc herniation may include annular fissures, Modic changes, or disc desiccation, but these must correlate with the patient’s clinical presentation. MRI is part of the puzzle, not the final answer.

7. Can We Correlate Herniation with Axial Pain?

Short answer: sometimes.

Several advanced diagnostic tools and principles help narrow down causation:

Provocative Discography: Now less commonly used, but still valuable when surgery is being considered. Reproduces the patient’s typical pain upon pressurizing the disc.
MRI with High-Intensity Zones (HIZ): A bright white spot on T2-weighted images indicating annular tears. While not definitive, it adds a data point.
Pain mapping with diagnostic blocks: Helps rule out other pain generators such as facet joints or the SI joint.
Concordant symptoms and exam: The most reliable “test” is when imaging findings match history, physical exam, and exclude other sources.

In sum, while we can’t always definitively prove a herniation causes axial pain, a pattern-based diagnostic approach increases clinical confidence.

Note: Provocative discography remains a debated test. It may help in surgical planning but is not routinely recommended due to invasiveness and false positives.

Treatment Options for Back Pain Disc Herniation

Treatment should always begin conservatively, with escalation only if pain persists and diagnostic clarity is achieved.

Conservative: Physical therapy, anti-inflammatory meds, postural retraining
Diagnostic Steps (to rule out other confounding issues): Medial branch blocks, SI joint injections to rule out other causes
Interventional: Intradiscal steroid injections, PRP injections, stem cell therapy, ViaDisc allograft, Intracept, Biacuplasty
Minimally Invasive Surgical: Disc-FX annuloplasty*, Endoscopic discectomy, annular modulation procedures

Disclaimer: Disc-FX, ViaDisc, PRP, and stem cell therapies are considered investigational by the FDA and are not approved for all spine indications. These options may be offered off-label with informed consent.

Older procedures like IDET (Intradiscal Electrothermal Therapy) are largely obsolete. Most modern practices favor biologic or targeted interventions instead of thermal or blind techniques.

Need help with back pain disc herniation?
Schedule an appointment with Dr. Amit Sharma and explore advanced treatment options including biologics and endoscopic spine surgery.Click here to book now